Jooni

An exemplary photo of a Hornbeam and Beech bonsai

Hornbeam and Beech

9 Species

Species

Carpinus caroliniana Carpinus betulus Carpinus japonica Carpinus laxiflora Carpinus orientalis Carpinus tschonoskii Carpinus turczaninowii Fagus crenata Fagus sylvatica

Hornbeam (Carpinus) and beech (Fagus) are closely related deciduous trees and two of the classic bonsai of temperate climates. Popular species include European hornbeam (Carpinus betulus), Korean hornbeam (Carpinus turczaninowii), Japanese hornbeam (Carpinus japonica), European beech (Fagus sylvatica) and Japanese white beech (Fagus crenata). Both are very hardy and need a cold winter dormancy, so they are strictly outdoor trees.

A hornbeam bonsai is a good choice for beginners: it grows vigorously, buds back well and develops fine twigs, fresh green leaves and yellow-orange autumn colour. Beech grows more slowly and is less forgiving of badly timed pruning, so it suits growers with some experience; its smooth grey bark and the brown leaves it holds through winter are its great charm.

At a glance Carpinus / Fagus

Difficulty
Intermediate
Placement
Outdoors
Light
Sun to partial shade
Watering
Moderate
Min. temperature
-10°C (14°F)
Foliage
Deciduous

Fertilizing

Feed from leaf-out until late summer. Use solid organic fertilizer every 4 weeks, or liquid fertilizer weekly at half strength.

  • Choose a fertilizer with trace elements to keep the leaves a healthy green.
  • Feed beech lightly until its spring shoots have hardened, so the new leaves and internodes stay short.
  • Stop feeding in autumn and winter, during dormancy.

Placement

Keep hornbeam and beech outdoors all year in a spot with good air circulation. Hornbeam grows well in full sun or partial shade, while beech prefers morning sun and afternoon shade, as its leaves scorch easily in hot sun and wind.

Both are very frost-hardy, but roots in a pot need protection below -10°C (14°F). Place the tree in a cold frame or an unheated shed or garage, or sink the pot into the ground. Never bring it into a heated room, where warm, dry air disrupts its dormancy.

Pruning

Let new shoots grow out, then cut them back to 1-2 leaves once they have 4-6 leaves and have begun to harden. Hornbeam produces several flushes and can be trimmed repeatedly until late summer, while beech usually makes only one flush a year.

  • Prune larger branches in late winter or early spring, before the buds open.
  • Leave at least one or two buds on every twig, as cutting into bare wood causes die-back.
  • Partially defoliating a healthy hornbeam in early summer reduces leaf size and improves ramification; don't do this on beech.

Wire while the tree is leafless or in early summer once the shoots have hardened. Check the wire often, because the smooth bark of both trees scars easily.

Repotting

Repot young trees every 2 years and older trees every 3-5 years, in early spring as the buds swell; beech is best repotted a little later, when its buds start to lengthen. Remove about a third of the old soil and roughly a quarter of the roots, focusing on thick, straight roots to encourage fine feeder roots.

  • Use a free-draining bonsai mix, such as akadama with pumice; both tolerate slightly acidic to slightly alkaline soil.
  • Don't bare-root an established tree in one go.
  • Water thoroughly and keep the tree sheltered until new growth shows it has recovered.

Watering

Keep the soil evenly moist and water thoroughly when the top layer begins to dry, but avoid waterlogged soil, which causes root rot. In summer, check daily, as trees in small pots may need water every day.

  • Water in the morning when possible, using a fine rose so the soil isn't washed out.
  • In winter, water sparingly but keep the root ball slightly moist, also in a shed or garage.

Seasonal care

  • Spring: Repot as the buds swell and prune larger branches before they open. Cut new shoots back once they harden, and start feeding after leaf-out.
  • Summer: Water daily in hot weather and give beech afternoon shade. Keep trimming hornbeam shoots to 1-2 leaves, and partially defoliate strong hornbeams in early summer if needed.
  • Autumn: Stop feeding and enjoy the autumn colour; beech and young hornbeams often keep dry brown leaves into winter. Wire bare branches once the leaves have fallen.
  • Winter: Keep the tree outdoors and protect the pot below -10°C (14°F). Remove the old dead leaves by hand in late winter, before the new buds open.

Common problems

Hornbeam and beech are robust, and most problems come from the weather or sap-sucking pests.

  • Leaf scorch: Brown, crispy leaf edges caused by hot sun, drying wind or a dry root ball, especially on beech. Provide afternoon shade and wind shelter in summer and never let the soil dry out.
  • Aphids and beech woolly aphid: Clusters of insects, or white waxy fluff under beech leaves, leave the leaves sticky and curled. Rinse them off with a strong jet of water and use an insecticide on heavy infestations.
  • Powdery mildew: A white coating on the leaves in humid summers with poor air movement. Thin the canopy, water the soil rather than the leaves and use a fungicide if needed.
  • Twig die-back: Usually caused by cutting into bare wood or pruning in winter without leaving buds. Always keep buds on the twigs and prune large branches just before the buds open.